The Great Progressive Tax Escape

IRS data show an accelerating flight from high-tax states.

  blob:https://www.wsj.com/0da182f4-ea22-4e9e-9f60-52d5c50e408d

 
Opinion Journal: Blue-State Republican Blues
 
Opinion Journal Video: Former CBO Director Doug Holtz-Eakin on the politics of tax reform in states like New York and California. Photo Credit: Getty Images.
 

Democrats contend that marginal tax rates don’t matter to investment and growth, and even some conservative intellectuals are conceding the point. But the evidence from wealth fleeing high-tax states shows how sensitive the affluent are to rate increases.

The liberal tax model is to fleece the rich to finance spending on entitlements and government programs that invariably grow faster than the economy and revenues. IRS data on tax migration show this model is now breaking down in progressive states as the affluent run for cover and the middle class is left paying the bills.

Between 2012 and 2015 (the most recent data), a net $8.5 billion in adjusted gross income left New Jersey while $6.2 billion poured out of Connecticut—4% of the latter state’s total income. Illinois lost $13.6 billion. During that period, Florida with no income tax gained $39.3 billion in AGI. (See the nearby table.)

The Great Progressive Tax Escape

 Not surprisingly, income flows down the tax gradient. In 2015 New York (where the combined state and local top rate is 12.7%) lost a net $850 million in AGI to New Jersey (8.97%) and Connecticut (6.99%). At the same time, the Garden State gave up $335 million to Pennsylvania (3.07%), and $60 million left Connecticut for the state formerly known as Taxachusetts (5.1%). Taxpayers from New York, New Jersey and Connecticut escaped to Florida with $3.2 billion in income. Florida Gov. Rick Scott ought to pay these states a commission. 

The affluent account for a disproportionate share of the income migration. For instance, individuals reporting more than $200,000 in AGI in 2015 made up 57% of the income outflow from Connecticut (compared to 48% of total state AGI) and 57% of the inflow to Florida.

Snowbird flight isn’t new, but migration has accelerated as taxes have increased. Income outflow from Connecticut averaged $500 million between 2003 and 2007. Then in 2009 GOP Gov. Jodi Rell raised the top tax rate to 6.5% from 5%, which her Democratic successor Dannel Malloy lifted a few years later to 6.7% and again two years ago to 6.99%. AGI outflow between 2012 and 2015 averaged $1.6 billion.

In 2004 Democrats raised New Jersey’s top rate on individuals earning more than $500,000 to 8.97% from 6.37%. Between 2012 and 2015, annual income outflow from New Jersey averaged $2.1 billion—twice as much as between 2000 and 2003 after adjusting for inflation.

Republican Gov. Chris Christie blocked his Democratic legislature’s attempts to reimpose a millionaire’s tax that lapsed in 2009. But Democratic Governor-elect won the election this month by promising to soak the rich even more, and his legislature will oblige.

The prospect of future tax hikes appears to have propelled an exodus of high earners from Illinois, which has a relatively low and flat 4.99% income tax. Democrats raised the rate from 3% in 2010, but the tax hike lapsed in 2015 after Bruce Rauner became Governor. House Speaker Michael Madigan finally this summer secured GOP legislative support to override the Governor’s veto and reinstate the higher rate.

But the tax increase won’t raise enough money to finance the state’s $250 billion unfunded pension liability, and the long-time goal of unions has been to enact a graduated income tax. The affluent know they’ll get soaked eventually and are seeking shelter. Top earners made up 47% of Illinois’s income flight in 2015 compared to 33% four years earlier. Income taxes from the 306 Cook County denizens who decamped to Palm Beach in 2015 with $258 million of income could have paid 200 teacher salaries. Alas.

This millionaires’ diaspora has harmed income and economic growth. Real GDP between 2011 and 2016 grew annually at a paltry 0.2% in Connecticut, 1% in Illinois and 1.2% in New Jersey, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. These states were the slowest growing in their respective geographic regions, though other high tax states in the Northeast didn’t fare much better.

As a result, revenues have repeatedly fallen short of projections in New Jersey, Illinois and Connecticut while budget deficits have ballooned. Democratic lawmakers have cut public services and funds to local governments, which have responded by raising property taxes.

The Tax Foundation says New Jersey, Connecticut, Vermont, New York and Illinois have the highest property taxes in the country. Over the last two years, the average Chicago homeowner’s property taxes have risen by roughly $1,000. Higher property taxes hit middle-class earners especially hard and are another incentive to leave a state.

***

As these state laboratories of Democratic governance show, dunning the rich ultimately hurts people of all incomes by repressing the growth needed to create jobs, boost wages and raise government revenues that fund public services. If the Republican House and Senate tax-reform bills follow through with eliminating all or part of the state and local tax deduction, progressive states will have an even harder time hiding the damage. They should be the next candidates for reform.

2 responses to The Great Progressive Tax Escape

  1. neilmaccallister November 14th, 2017 at 9:15 pm

    The WSJ is a waste of energy for Pres. Donald Trump.

    Do you know what would be great? ..enlivening? ..and supportive of a man with as many strong sinews in his thought as has Donald Trump??

    Give a call to a friend, Herman Cain!

    “9-9-9” !!!

    …Why not?

    What do you say? ..Mr. Stephen Moore?

    Is America finally ready to STAND UP???

    Just a little? ..in ANY way???

    ***

    Herman Cain is as “Blue Collar” as it gets!

    …just like Trump!!

    Why not let real MEN and WOMEN (..thank you, Sarah!!) walk the halls of Washington DC??

    Are we gonna sit here and DIE in this filth-filled trench?

    ..or do you want to try to survive???

    ***

    Please, Mr. Cain, ..please call the President, and offer your significant skills in satisfying contracts wtitten with 300 million signatories!

    You’ve been there, ..as has Donald Trump (at times).

    Why don’t you compare notes with the President?

    ..and get this great nation out of the GUTTER that it so BLINDLY believes is “the new normal”?

    Thank you, Herman Cain.

    Thank you, Donald Trump.

    I’m off to work, too.

        Reply

  2. neilmaccallister November 14th, 2017 at 9:25 pm

    P.s.,

    Mr. Cain??? ..what would YOU do with Mr. Jeffery Sessions??

    You know, ..that guy eitting over there, collecting a paycheck which equals my lifetime earnings, every month!!!

    Really, is Jeffery worth retaining???

        Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *